Yost Takes Legal Action to Protect Rare Book Collection at Hebrew Union College in Cincinnati

Dave_Yost_Header
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
June 4, 2024MEDIA CONTACT:
Hannah Hundley: 614-906-9113


Yost Takes Legal Action to Protect Rare Book Collection at Hebrew Union College in Cincinnati

(CINCINNATI, Ohio) — Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost is seeking a temporary restraining order to prevent the sale of copies of the Talmud and other ancient books housed in Cincinnati’s Klau Library at Hebrew Union College.

Through the years, donors have given money to fund the library and care for the rare books and manuscripts..

“These sacred texts are invaluable artifacts — religious and cultural treasures.” AG Yost said. “Their sale would not only betray donor trust but also may violate legal restrictions placed on the gifts.”

Yost’s legal action follows revelations that the college, the first permanent Jewish institution of higher learning in America, has indicated interest in selling some of the precious texts to offset its sizable deficits.

The Klau Library collection includes 14,000 items in the Rare Book Room, some potentially worth millions of dollars. The texts were entrusted to the library with the understanding that they would be preserved and maintained for use by scholars and researchers worldwide. The academic community relies on access to these texts — an integral part of the library’s public service and educational roles.

If sold to private collectors, the books would no longer be publicly available. Any sale could be a breach of the Hebrew Union board’s fiduciary duties to the library’s public beneficiaries. And, for books that can be sold, sale proceeds must be used to acquire other collection items. Using sale proceeds to reduce the college’s deficit could constitute an illegal use of assets donated expressly to fund the collection.

In his filing yesterday in Hamilton County Common Pleas Court, Yost asks the court to halt any potential sale, highlighting the importance of honoring donor intent and preserving the integrity of institutional missions. A hearing on the matter will be held today at 11 a.m.

“A library without its most precious artifacts and texts is like a body without a soul,” he said. “We are committed to ensuring that these irreplaceable items remain available to the public and are cared for as their donors intended.”–30–Dave_Yost_Footer

Ohio Attorney General Partners with OSU and Nonprofit to Study Charitable Impacts During COVID-19 Pandemic

Like other sectors, COVID-19 is limiting how charities operate with a new study showing that more than one in four Ohio nonprofits are not able to provide any services due to its economic fallout and an additional 50% are doing so at a significantly reduced capacity.

The Ohio Attorney General’s Office partnered with Philanthropy Ohio and Ohio State University’s John Glenn School of Public Affairs to produce The Ohio Nonprofit COVID-19 Survey which captured early reactions of the nonprofit sector to the pandemic, including their concerns and planned actions.

“Everyone is making financial decisions that will hopefully limit their long-term impact,” Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost said. “The stark reality is that even small cuts to Ohio charities will have large consequences. Remember your fellow Ohioan when budgeting cuts for charities – they need us more now more than ever.” 

The study began in early April in response to the public health crisis and received more than 7,700 responses from charities and nonprofits throughout the state. With input from several members of the Ohio Attorney General’s Charitable Advisory Council, the project partners plan to field further rounds of the survey in the coming months to track how nonprofits are overcoming and recovering from the coronavirus pandemic.

Without the ability to host large gatherings, cancellations and postponements are happening rapidly and are not limited to the state’s larger cities. Large charity events such as the American Heart Association’s Heart Mini-Marathon and Walk — Cincinnati’s largest fundraiser — have been cancelled or postponed statewide over the past two months. The Komen Columbus Race for the Cure, originally scheduled for May 16, has been postponed until August 1. With delays and cancellations, food banks throughout Ohio are feeding more people with limited resources.

“The sector is resilient, but keeping nonprofit doors open depends heavily on the goodwill of funders and volunteers,” said Dr. Erynn Beaton of the John Glenn School of Public Affairs. “I want this study to draw attention to the challenges these organizations face – at a time when people need them most. There are many nonprofits struggling, and even the smallest donations can help.”

The report found that the following revenue streams are “very important” to survey participants:

  • Individual donations (68.7% of respondents)
  • Business or corporate donations (43.7%)
  • Foundation grants (30.9%)
  • Earned income like service fees and charges (28.8%)
  • Membership dues (28.5%)
  • Government grants and contracts (23.2%)

Responding nonprofits already are cutting administrative expenses, applying for the Federal Payroll Protection Program and cutting or furloughing staff. About 18% of them have had to draw on reserves and others are strongly considering it.

“Philanthropy Ohio is grateful for the nonprofits who are working under difficult circumstances to continue their services to clients and communities,” said Deborah Aubert Thomas, president and CEO of Philanthropy Ohio. “We are glad that so many foundations, companies and United Ways are stepping up to help, as seen by the more than 55 COVID-19 relief funds – with more than 116 organizations – across Ohio that have raised about $26 million and disbursed over $15 million since the crisis began.”

Philanthropy Ohio is an association of foundations, corporate giving programs, individuals and organizations actively involved in philanthropy in Ohio.

Charitable organizations fulfill a vital role in Ohioans’ quality of life. The attorney general’s office provides a variety of resources, including a database of registered charities, to help charitable leaders serve their communities and reassure donors that their contributions are being used as they intend.

For more information, click here.

NASCO Annual Report on State Regulation and Enforcement

NASCO is pleased to release its Annual Report on State Regulation and Enforcement covering January 2019-March 2020.  The report provides a representative sample of cases and other initiatives in the areas of: I. Deceptive Solicitation; II. Governance and Breach of Fiduciary Duties; III. Trust & Estate Issues; IV. Health Care; and V. Other, including Registration, Legislation, and Guidance.  Thank you to our state members and our federal counterparts for providing the descriptions of their important work. View the full report here.

Iowa Attorney General Tom Miller Dismantles National ‘Puppy Laundering’ Ring

Settlement of unprecedented lawsuit dissolves ‘rescue’ organizations 

DES MOINES — Iowans who operated an alleged puppy laundering ring have agreed to dissolve their “pet rescue” nonprofits, permanently cease deceptive operations, pay the state $60,000, and submit to other restrictions as part of a settlement with Iowa Attorney General Tom Miller. 

Continue reading “Iowa Attorney General Tom Miller Dismantles National ‘Puppy Laundering’ Ring”

Illnois Attorney General Raoul Announces Settlement in Puerto Rican Parade Committee Banktruptcy Case

Former Committee’s Leadership Prohibited from Operating Charities in Illinois

Attorney General Kwame Raoul today announced a settlement with the Puerto Rican Parade Committee (PRPC) that will help fund the annual Puerto Rican Peoples Parade and festival that is now organized by a new charity.

Continue reading “Illnois Attorney General Raoul Announces Settlement in Puerto Rican Parade Committee Banktruptcy Case”